A gridbased approximation algorithm for the minimum. The minimum weight triangulation problem is notorious as one of the problems which are not known to be nphard nor solvable in polynomial time for a long time 8. B compute triangulation of p of minimum total length. All four algorithms rely on the same abstract divideandconquer scheme, which is made e. Minimum weight triangulation is nphard freie universitat berlin. Minimum weight triangulation is nphard proceedings of the. Wessels general audience abstract given a set of npoints on a plane p, a triangulation of pis a set of edges such that no two edges intersect at a point not in p, and the edges subdivide the convex hull of pinto triangles. Computational geometry theory and computing a subgraph. Minimum weight triangulation the minimum weight triangulation short mwt is, among all possible triangulations, the triangulation that has the minimum total edge length. Minimum weight triangulation method based on memoization dynamic programming is a technique that analyzes the solution of problems with methods based on the principles of optimization. However, when the points are in convex position, the problem can be solved in polynomial time by dynamic programming. We will show that the optimal polygon triangulation can be solved by the dynamic programming approach. It was one of the few longstanding open problems from.
Its actually a fairly common algorithm, however i just cant grasp it. The same dynamic programming approach can also be extended to the case that the. Computational geometry theory and computing a subgraph of the. Minimum weight triangulation dynamic programming algorithm. Lloyd 1977 provided examples which show that both proposed algorithms usually do not compute the mwt fig. A branchandcut approach for minimum weight triangulation. For large point sets, however, mere dynamic programming becomes absolutely. Given a set of vertices s, the minimum weight triangulation problem mwts. Any line intersecting the polygon crosses the boundary at most twice. Optimality and integer programming formulations of triangulations in general dimension. Dynamic programming is used to solve problems which have overlapping subproblems. Paper a gpu implementation of dynamic programming for the.
The main result in this paper is an exact algorithm to compute. Minimum weight triangulation is nphard proceedings of. The minimum weight triangulation problem is to find a triangulation t of minimum length for a given set of points p in the euclidean plane. A triangulation of a planar point set s is a maximal plane straightline graph with vertex set s. Gilbert4 and, independently, klincsek5 provided an 0n3 time dynamic programming algorithm for computing the minimum weight triangulation of a simple polygon. In this paper we show that a polynomially computable euclidean graph, the disk based tzskeleton is always a subgraph of the minimum weight triangulation. Especially the combination of the diamond property and the lmtskeleton made it possible to compute the mwt for large, wellbehaved point sets. Memoization method for storing of minimum weight triangulation of a convex polygon this study presents a practical view of dynamic programming, specifically in the context of the application of finding the optimal solutions for the polygon triangulation problem. The minimum weighted triangulation is the triangulation of a polygon where the sum of all the edges or perimeter of every triangle is the smallest. In fact, this problem has become one of the stan dard textbook examples or exercises for illustrating the dynamic programming paradigm. Overview of the complexity status of di erent triangulation problems.
The cost of a triangulation is sum of the weights of its component triangles. Given a set of vertices s, the minimum weight triangulation problem mwts consists of nding the triangulation of the set s such that the sum of the eucledian lengths of the edges is a minimum. A convex polygon p on n vertices in the plane speci. Besides the two triangulations of type l and r, there are mixed forms where the transition between l and r can occur in intermediate. The main result in this paper is an exact algorithm to compute a. In 1979, garey and johnson listed minimum weight triangulation mwt as one of a dozen important problems not known to be in p nor nphard 15. The algorithm, based on dynamic programming, constructs the optimal triangulation of a larger domain from the. As of now, only two problems from the original list remain open, namely precedence. Pdf minimum weight triangulation by cutting out triangles. Greedy and the delaunay triangulations are computable in linear time and space for. The minimum weight triangulation mwt minimizes the total edge length.
The minimum weight triangulation problem with few inner points. Minimumweight triangulation is nphard 3 this list have been resolved by proving nphardness or by exhibiting a polynomialtime algorithm see johnson 2005 for a recent status update on the list. In the minimumweight triangulation mwt problem, we are looking for a triangulation of a given. An heuristic algorithm for the minimum weight triangulation. Solving largescale minimumweight triangulation instances. There have also been attempts to attack the general problem with dynamic programming techniques. Triangulate each remaining region optimally using the dynamicprogramming algorithm. The minimum weight triangulation of a simple polygon can be computed in o n 3 time and o n 2 space. Cost of a triangulation is given by the sum of lengths of diagonals in it. In 2006 the problem was nally shown to be nphard 28. A triangulation of p is a collection of n3 diagonals of p such that no towo diagonals intersect. On3, using dynamic programming mwt of a polygon with holes or of a set of points in the plane is nphard minweight steiner triangulation.
There have also been attempts to attack the general problem with dynamic programmingtechniques. The minimum weight triangulation is obtained as the minimum over all resulting triangulations. However, when the points are in convex position, the problem can be solved in polynomial time by dynamic programming, 19. Construct a lexicographically ordered list, q, of contours. Algorithms for optimal area triangulations of a convex polygon core.
Lecture 12 dynamic programming continued triangulation of a convex polygon a polygon is a twodimensional closed shape defined by connections between points or vertices. This means that it finds the weight the sum of all the triangle perimeters, as well as. Computing the minimum weight triangulation of a set of. Memoization method for storing of minimumweight triangulation of a convex polygon this study presents a practical view of dynamic programming, specifically in the context of the application of finding the optimal solutions for the polygon triangulation problem. The minimum weight triangulation problem has a long and rich history, dating. The minimum weight triangulation problem with few inner. The problem is to find the cost of triangulation with the minimum cost. We consider the problem of computing a minimum weight pseudotriangulation of a set s of n points in the plane. Pdf we describe a fixed parameter algorithm for computing the minimum weight triangulation mwt of a simple polygon with nk vertices on the. A gridbased approximation algorithm for the minimum weight. Next, a minimum weight triangulation of the polygon is found by dynamic programming.
That is, an input polygon or the convex hull of an input point set must be subdivided into triangles that meet edgetoedge and vertextovertex, in such a way as to minimize the sum of the perimeters of the triangles. The lmtskeleton algorithm often yields a connected graph, such that the remaining polygonal faces can be triangulated with dynamic programming to obtain the. Minimumweight triangulation mwt of a simple polygon. An algorithm for triangulating 3d polygons ming zou washington university in st. If the polygon is convex, a triangulation of weight ologn times. Pdf memoization method for storing of minimumweight. The problem has a subexponential time exact algorithm 32, as well as a polynomialtime approximation scheme ptas for random inputs 18. Thanks for contributing an answer to computer science. However, when the points are in convex position, the problem can be solved in polynomial time by dynamic programming,18. On a linear program for minimum weight triangulation cs. On a linear program for minimumweight triangulation. Every triangulation of a simple polygon with n vertices has n 3 diagonals and n 2 triangles. A set of n points, p, lying on k lin early ordered lines. Minimumweight triangulation is nphard wolfgang mulzer princeton university and gunter rote.
The exact minimum weight triangulation of a simple polygon can be found by dynamic program ming in time on3 10, 12. In the minimum weight triangulation mwt problem, we are looking for a triangulation of a given point set that minimizes the sum of the edge lengths. Finding a minimum weight triangulation is one of the few natural problems whose complexity remain unknown. It makes a difference whether it is allowed to add new points, socalled steiner points, to the planar point set. Approximating the minimum weight steiner triangulation.
When the cost of an edge is its length, a minimum cost triangulation is called a minimum length triangulation, or more popularly and less logically, a minimum weight triangulation mwt. Dynamic programming continued triangulation of a convex polygon a polygon is a twodimensional closed shape defined by connections between points or vertices. Therefore a triangulation is a plane graph where every interior face is a triangle, and the boundary of the exterior face coincides with the convex hull of s. The minimum weight triangulation problem is notorious as one of the problems which are not known to be nphard nor solvable in polynomial time 12. Another related problem is minimum weight pseudotriangulation which asks for a pseudotriangulation of minimum weight. Minimum weight triangulation computer science stack exchange. Solving largescale minimumweight triangulation instances to. In the minimumweight triangulation mwt problem, we are looking for a triangulation of a given po. This function will be recursive, so the first call should be mwt0, n1, where n is the total number of vertices.
A study of generating minimum weight triangulation within practical time. A gridbased approximation algorithm for the minimum weight triangulation problem mari ette c. In computational geometry and computer science, the minimum weight triangulation problem is the problem of finding a triangulation of minimal total edge length. The minimum weight triangulation mwt problem seeks to nd a triangulation t of pwith the smallest possible weight. In the minimum weight triangulation mwt problem, we are. Chapter 16 dynamic programming element of a candidate. A new heuristic for minimum weight triangulation siam. It has been shown that the mwt is the best triangulation for 3dimensional area interpolations.
It was introduced by bellman in the 1950s when programming meant planning, and is typically applied to optimization problems. Matrices twodimensional arrays can be multiplied by the standard formulas from linear algebra. It has a polynomialtime constantfactor approximation algorithm,and avariety ofe. Minimum weight triangulation by cutting out triangles. In 1979, garey and johnson listed minimumweight triangulation mwt as one of a dozen important problems not known to be in p nor nphard 15. I make a function that returns the minimum weight triangulation, which i call mwti, j of a polygon starting at vertex i and going to vertex j. In computational geometry and computer science, the minimumweight triangulation problem is. Weight of each triangle is its perimeter sum of lengths of all sides see following example taken from this source. A triangulation is a maximal, planar, straightline graph. This algorithm can be used to compute the minimum weight triangulation of a point set s in the following way. I understand how the iterative version dynamic programming ie. For a contour y let ty denote a minimum weight triangulation of the points x. Note that the mwt also referred to as the optimal triangulation for a given point set is not necessarily unique.
Dynamic programming i dynamic programming is a powerful, tabular method that solves problems by combining solutions to subproblems. Paper a gpu implementation of dynamic programming for. Eppstein, david 1994, approximating the minimum weight steiner triangulation pdf, discrete and computational geometry, 11 2. Minimumweight triangulation is nphard journal of the acm. Browse other questions tagged polygon minimum triangulation decomposition or ask your own question. Minimumweight triangulation method based on memoization dynamic programming is a technique that analyzes the solution of problems with methods based on the principles of optimization. Minimum cost polygon triangulation using dynamic programming. Lingas, greedy triangulation approximates the minimum weight triangulation and can be computed in linear time in the average case, report lucstr.
1103 467 1079 1268 490 1481 1402 1610 901 369 216 1426 230 991 52 1124 1476 526 898 988 1228 1464 143 402 1439 819 767 1045 1549 884 222 616 1508 661 20 239 381 736 1437 1437 901 416 221